Skip to main content
The Sole Supplier
  • Footwear
    Best Selling TrainersUpcoming Trainer ReleasesLatest Trainer Releases
    • nike trainers
    • Air Force 1
    • Dunk
    • Air Max 90
    • Air Max 270
    • Air Max 95
    • Air Max 97
    • Air Huarache
    • Blazer
    • Air Max 1
    • Air VaporMax
    • Air Max 98
    • TN Air Max Plus
    • View all
    • Jordan trainers
    • Air Jordan 1
    • Air Jordan 4
    • Air Jordan 11
    • Air Jordan 5
    • Air Jordan 3
    • Air Jordan 6
    • Air Jordan 13
    • Air Jordan 12
    • Air Jordan 2
    • Air Jordan Mars 270
    • Air Jordan 7
    • Air Jordan 23
    • adidas trainers
    • Gazelle
    • Terrex
    • Samba
    • Ozweego
    • Forum
    • Ultra Boost
    • Superstar
    • Continental 80
    • Spezial
    • ZX 750
    • Stan Smith
    • NMD
    • View all
    • yeezy trainers
    • Boost 700
    • Boost 350
    • Boost 380
    • 500
    • Slides
    • Foam Runner
    • Quantum
    • 450
    • Boot
    • View all
    • new balance trainers
    • 990
    • 991
    • 992
    • 550
    • 327
    • 373
    • 574
    • 2002R
    • M997
    • 530
    • View all
    • converse trainers
    • Chuck Taylor All Star
    • Chuck 70
    • x CDG Play
    • x Off-White
    • One Star
    • x JW Anderson
    • Jack Purcell
    • Runstar Hike
    • Pro
    • View all
    • Sport
    • Running Shoes
    • Gym/Training Shoes
    • Basketball Shoes
    • Football Boots
    • Skate Shoes
    • Tennis Shoes
    • Trail Running Shoes
    • Style
    • High Tops
    • Flip Flops/Sliders
    • Slip On
    • Winter
    • Material
    • Leather
    • Vegan
    • Waterproof
    • Suede
    • Canvas
    • Colour
    • Black
    • White
    • Blue
    • Red
    • Green
    • Grey
    • Yellow
    • Orange
    • Pink
    • Brown
    • Beige
    • Silver
    • Gold
    • Purple
    • Multi
  • Clothing
    Latest Products
    • Gilets
    • Hoodies
    • Jackets & Coats
    • Joggers & Tracksuit Bottoms
    • Shorts
    • Socks
    • Sweatshirts
    • Swimwear
    • T-Shirts & Tops
    • Track Tops
    • Tracksuits
    • Trousers
    • View all
    • a

    • adidas
    • Arc'teryx
    • c

    • Carhartt
    • Champion
    • Cole Buxton
    • f

    • Fear of God ESSENTIALS
    • l

    • Levis
    • n

    • New Balance
    • Nike
    • o

    • Off-White
    • s

    • Stussy
    • t

    • The North Face
  • news
  • reminders
  • raffles
  • sale
  • womens
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Not So Supreme (Italia) ...
Not So Supreme (Italia) Anymore
exclusive
Image via Brandon McGhee

Not So Supreme (Italia) Anymore

Karl Smith
By Karl Smith • Contributing Writer • 10 Aug, 2021 1:26 PM

We may earn a commission when you buy something from links on this page.

Learn More

Last month, after a lengthy legal battle, father and son business duo Michelle and Marcello di Pierro were sentenced to serious jail time and slapped with a £7.5 million GBP fine.

Their crime? Founding, expanding, and ultimately profiting from their brand: Supreme Italia.

You might be wondering what part of that, exactly, lands a person behind bars. You might also be wondering if Supreme Italia has anything to do with a certain box-logo-loving brand from New York City.

The good news is that these are basically the same question. Or, at least, two halves of one whole that really only serve to conjure further queries: first, on a practical level, about the limits of creativity and intellectual property; secondly, in a more existential sense, about authenticity – about what happens when a brand loses sight of its founding principles and, in a sense, its soul.

But let's start with the second part: what is Supreme Italia and how is it related to the skate brand founded by James Jebbia back in 1994?

Not So Supreme (Italia) Anymore
Supreme Italia's Shanghai Flagship. Image via Brandon McGhee

Supreme Italia is a canny sleight of hand, the product of several loopholes – cleverly exploited by the di Pierro family – allowing them to create and sell what are known as “legal fakes.” In this case, that means knock-off Supreme merchandise – with all the right fonts, logos, branding; the whole shebang – that isn't technically a knock-off at all thanks to some shrewd trademarking moves.

In short: it's not fake Supreme, it's real Supreme Italia.

Now, if this sounds a little less than on the level, that's because – for all the legal smoke and mirrors – it very much is. There's a reason, after all, that di Pierro was forced to shutter Supreme Italia – although not before the business expanded from online trading to brick and mortar stores in Italy, Spain, and even into Mainland China before Supreme Proper even set foot in the market.

Naturally, Supreme were none too happy with the “parasitic competition” of their Italian counterpart. Being beaten to the punch in one of the world's biggest and fastest growing markets – not just by a competitor, but by an imposter trading on your own brand identity – does seem like it might just sting a little. Smarting enough, at least, to formally start legal proceedings.

Now, in one sense, di Pierro – staring down the barrel of just the latest in a long line of fashion-related fraud cases that point to the mind of a grifter rather than a business genius – doesn't really have a legal or ethical leg to stand on with any of this. There is, and hopefully will always be, room for bootlegging in sneaker and streetwear cultures: the kind of creativity and artistry that customisation brings to the community is part of its lifeblood.

That being said, there is also very much a limit to how far that can or should be pushed – a limit set by motivations and intentions, more than anything else. That di Pierro’s sole intention seems to have been getting rich off the back of the Supreme brand sets him apart from the other creators – all fans at their core, motivated by passion for the craft.

One of these things is certainly not like the other.

Not So Supreme (Italia) Anymore
Supreme Italia's Shanghai Flagship. Image via Brandon McGhee

And yet, for all his many flaws, di Pierro and the orchestrated demise of Supreme Italia make some salient points about Supreme’s own origins, its values, and the resemblance that the global brand we know today bears to the irreverent upstart founded 27 years ago.

As part of his defence before the Italian courts, di Pierro pointed out the irony of Supreme’s complaint: that their entire visual identity was, essentially, cribbed from the artist Barbara Kruger.

In a sense, of course, Supreme’s whole thing is trading off of popular culture icons – movies, musicians, artists, and even other brands – to shore up their own position as a part of that creative legacy. But that only works – or, at the very least, that only feels legitimate – when you have a strong identity of your own to begin with.

It's not the first time someone has joined the dots here, either – although somehow Jebbia and co. never quite seem to arrive at naming Kruger as a part of their story – and the artist herself has made no secret of her frustrations.

Her 2017 Volcom collaboration – selling familiar red and white box logo merchandise with a bold Futura typeface – was less than subtle. Her calling Supreme “totally uncool jerks,” after the apparent final straw of the brand’s lawsuit against fellow streetwear label Married To The Mob for trademark infringement, even less so.

And, of course, Kruger is right. Calling out your impersonators is a strange position to take when you’ve effectively built your own brand off the back of another artist’s creative work. Putting aside the audacity and dubious moral standing of the whole thing, why would anyone ever want to draw attention to that?

Not So Supreme (Italia) Anymore
Supreme Italia's Shanghai Flagship. Image via Brandon McGhee

The obvious answer, of course, is money. And, realistically, Supreme has been a brand focused on making money – rather than making any meaningful contribution to the culture – for some time now: the sale of a 50% stake to the Carlyle Group in 2017, valuing the brand at approximately $1 billion USD – and that group’s subsequent sale to VF Corporation, which owns Vans and The North Face, late last year in a deal which more than doubled that valuation – are both testament to where Supreme stands these days.

Pursuing value over values and capital over creativity, Supreme is now a corporate force to be reckoned with, rather than any kind of plucky disruptor. There are no more peers, only competitors. No more flattering imitations or up and coming brands to inspire – only infringements and potential lawsuits.

Naturally, Supreme Italia should never have existed. Or, at least, it shouldn’t have been allowed to exist for so long, making so much money for its founders. But Supreme’s ruthless pursuit of the brand shines an unflattering light on its own history and its own legacy.

Supreme as we knew it is long dead. Long live Supreme.

Not So Supreme (Italia) Anymore
Supreme Italia's Shanghai Flagship. Image via Brandon McGhee
subscribe
discoverThe hottestsneaker news
Get the latest sneaker and streetwear news and releases from your favourite brands with The Sole Supplier email subscription.

Recent news

The adidas Forum 84 Low Pink Colourway

The adidas Forum 84 Low "Pink" is the Perfect Summer Sneaker

4 hours ago · Raphael Paz

Nike TN France 2exclusive

The Nike TN "France" Is Still Available to Cop Now!

5 hours ago · Jack Aldrich

New Balance 2002R Brown Hiking Boots

This New Balance 2002R Pulls Inspiration From Traditional Hiking Boots

5 hours ago · Raphael Paz

TermsSeller TermsPrivacyAboutContactMeet The TeamEditorial PolicyCareers
The Sole Supplier
70 CKR House
East Hill
Dartford
DA1 1RZ
Download on the App Store

Get the latest releases, dates, news and your favourite brands on The Sole Supplier app.

© 2022 Sole Supplier® . All rights Reserved® Company Reg No. 09098756